"Maliciousness" suggests an awareness of the potential outcome, which was absent in this case, leading to the overturning of his conviction.
Nevertheless, the courts presume that the individual must have been cognizant of the risk involved (given his knowledge of the phone's composition, like bakelite), based on the circumstances.
The defendant took out a gas metre with the intention of stealing money from it, constituting a separate charge and conviction. As a result, gas began to leak and caused partial asphyxiation of a neighbour.
The charge against the defendant was based on section 23 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861, which prohibited the unlawful and malicious administration of a harmful substance to someone else.
The court's approach employs an objective standard by presuming the defendant's awareness based on circumstantial evidence. This raises a pertinent question about whether the court adequately considered the defendant's personal awareness of the risks involved, as opposed to relying solely on an objective viewpoint. The case underscores the intricate interplay between subjective and objective elements in assessing criminal intent.
A man wrenched the gas meter off a house to get the money inside. This caused gas to enter the next-door house and endanger the life of a woman living there.
The charge involved there being a “malicious” action, which the judge directed that there was. The jury convicted him.
His appeal was allowed on the grounds that “maliciousness” implies a foresight of the result and that, this being lacking, his conviction was quashed.
However the courts merely assume that the man must have known the risk he was taking (because he knew the phone was made from bakelite, etc.) because of the circumstances.
This is effectively an objective test therefore because the judges are failing to consider whether the man himself was aware of the risks he was taking, and do not prove that he was.
Ask questions 🙋 Get answers 📔 It's simple 👁️👄👁️
Our AI is educated by the highest scoring students across all subjects and schools. Join hundreds of your peers today.
Get StartedThese product samples contain the same concepts we cover in this case.
GDL Criminal Law | Mens Rea Notes (9 pages) |