This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more

L’Oreal v Bellure [2011] 9 E.I.P.R., 550

By Oxbridge Law TeamUpdated 04/01/2024 07:13

Judgement for the case L’Oreal v Bellure

  • Defendant produced 3 “smell-a-likes” of 3 perfumes made by Claimant (L’Oreal). The names of each of the perfumes imitated was protected by a trade mark.

  • Claimant claimed that its trade marks relating to the 3 perfumes were infringed by:

    1. Defendant’s packaging, which sought to imitate that of Claimant; however this claim dropped.

    2. “Comparison lists” used by Defendant (i.e. lists on the back of packages indicating which of Defendant’s perfumes smelled like which of Claimant’s) - E.g. “Stitch No 7 smells like Trésor”

  • Held:

ECJ (2009)

  • Judgement related to Article 5(1)(a)

Facts

  • In present case, use of trade mark was not descriptive (as in Arsenal FC), rather it was for comparative purposes

  • Thus was used for purpose of advertising

Court of Appeal (2010)

Jacobs LJ

  • Article 5(1)(a)

    • “I have real difficulty” in dealing with the communication / advertisement / investment functions

      • Is nothing in legislation about them

      • Are conceptually vague and ill-defined

    • Appears to be that any comparative advertising is banned.

      • I.e. as it will automatically impinge on advertisement function.

  • Article 5(2)

    • Court appears to be saying that where advantage is taken of an earlier trademark, this is automatically unfair.

    • Thus is no distinction between:

      1. Permissible free-riding

      2. Impermissible free-riding

    • This amounts to pointless monopoly.

Facts

  • On basis of ECJ’s preliminary judgment:

    1. Comparison lists breach Article 5(1)(a), as they adversely affect advertising function of Claimant’s mark

    2. Comparison lists also breach of Article 5(2), as they take advantage of reputation of Claimant’s mark

Any comments or edits about this case? Get in touch

For Further Study on L’Oreal v Bellure

Intellectual Property Law Notes
1,014 total pages
1033 purchased

IP law notes fully updated for recent exams at Oxford and Cambridge. Th...

Intellectual Property Law Notes
446 total pages
22 purchased

My notes cover all the main cases in intellectual property law. They a...

Need instant answers? Our AI exam tutor is here to help.

Ask questions 🙋 Get answers 📔 It's simple 👁️👄👁️

Our AI is educated by the highest scoring students across all subjects and schools. Join hundreds of your peers today.

Get Started
Claim every advantage to get a first in law
Intellectual Property Law Notes
446 total pages
22 purchased

My notes cover all the main cases in intellectual property law. They a...