This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more

Accounting Notes Accounting in the New Public Sector Notes

Topic 2 Reading The Attitudes Of Nhs Clinicians And Medical Managers Towards Changes In Accounting Controls Notes

Updated Topic 2 Reading The Attitudes Of Nhs Clinicians And Medical Managers Towards Changes In Accounting Controls Notes

Accounting in the New Public Sector Notes

Accounting in the New Public Sector

Approximately 80 pages

AC310: Management Accounting, Financial Management and Organizational Control - Module 4 (Accounting in the New Public Sector).

These notes cover the final module of the AC310 Management Accounting course at LSE which covers the following topics: Management accounting and financial management in the 'New Public Sector', including performance measurement, cost accounting, cost management and pricing; the roles of accounting controls in the health system reforms in the UK and elsewhere.

These not...

The following is a more accessible plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our Accounting in the New Public Sector Notes. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:

Introduction

  • Delegation of responsibility for health care to the point of delivery, envisaged by the NHS reforms (Department of Health, 1989)

Context of change

Intensifying pressures for change

  • Followed the 1970s oil crisis (Klein and O’Higgins, 1985)

  • Cash limits were introduced in 1976 and continuous efforts were made by successive governments in Britain and many countries overseas, to find ways of improving efficiency and curtailing expenditure (Abel-Smith, 1984)

  • Contractual or quasi-market forms, increasing delegation of resource decisions, more explicit and measurable standards, weakening trust in professionals, strengthening the hand of managers (Dunleavy and Hood, 1994)

  • Externally imposed pressures

  • Challenged culture within health care

  • Griffiths’ management inquiry (DHSS, 1983) – NHS was a corporate or clan culture based upon the dominance of doctors and their clinical freedom

    • Proposals:

      • Appointment of general managers

      • Decentralization of cost and budget systems

      • Hierarchic control system (Bourn and Ezzamel, 1986)

  • Internal markets… in the pursuit of efficiency and cost reduction

    • ‘Competition with other hospitals where it is effective, should also constrain costs’ (Department of Health, 1989)

  • Revised organizational goals, devolved financial accountability to clinicians, threatened deep-seated cultures, challenged the balance of power between clinicians and administrators

  • Resistance to revised control philosophies, such as managerial model proposed by the Griffiths Report (1983)

Organisational implications of the reforms

  • Commercial ethos potentially conflicted with the dual hierarchies

  • Hierarchies became more closely integrated

  • Administrators/managers were appointed

  • Literature related to the sociology of professions suggests that such imposition of formalized rules and procedures is unnecessary, and may even cause professional-bureaucratic conflict, leading to impaied performance (Hall, 1972)

Implications for accounting control systems of organizational change

  • Nelson and Machin (1976)

    • suggested a model of control, based on breaking down goals and objectives

    • concentration on budgetary control was too simplistic for public services such as the NHS

    • costs and inputs cannot be related quantitatively to measures of outcome

  • Empirical study of resource allocation in the NHS, Nahapiet (1988):

    • “…relationship between accounting and organization is a complex web of multiple connections and mutual inflences evolving over time”

  • “Resistance and skepticism”

    • Resistance can lead to failure, and the management budgeting initiative was such a case (DHSS HN)

  • Resource Management Initiative (1986)

    • GPs delegated unwelcome changes in financial and administrative procedures to practice managers and nurses, leaving their own role virtually unchanged

  • Purdy (1993) observed ‘natural learning’ among ward sisters who appreciated accounting information providing they had been involved in budgeting and that activities were properly resourced

  • Reasons to accounting-type controls were conditional upon contextual factors which potentially shaped the controls

  • Accounting controls cannot be successfully imposed upon unwilling recipients

  • 1990 reforms moved the control philosophies of units within the NHS towards those found within large commercial organisations

    • Sophisticated and complex control systems (Bruns and Waterhouse, 1975

  • Accounting information has been criticized as being inaccurate, too late and too aggregated (Dew and Gee, 1973)

    • These limitations have encouraged the creation of informal non-legitimized records (Clancy and Collins, 1979)

      • These enhance the knowledge and hence the power or subordinates (Pettigrew, 1972)

Process of change

Symbolism of formal accounting information

  • At the beginning of the study, the majority of clinical directors and operational managers anticipated that ACSs would be of high importance for overall institutional control

    • Sense of resignation that this was an inevitable consequence of the intensifying pressures on the NHS

  • CDs and OMs were less convinced than finance staff of the importance of ACSs for the functioning of the revised structure

    • Finance staff perceived formal ACSs to be of the highest order of potential importance

  • Service managers were less convinced of the importance of ACSs for overall institutional control

    • Some displayed rather more optimistic and altruistic opinions concerning the ability of the institution to balance financial and medical priorities

  • Cultural difficulties and shortcomings in information as factors which inhibited the realization of the anticipated importance of ACS information

    • “Consultants in directorates are now more accountable for how they spend money. It is a slow process, a whole culture has to be changed”

    • “Appreciation of the reforms, by colleagues, has been slow”

  • Progressively adopting the language of managerialism, although their expectations still did not match those of the finance staff

  • SM and OM expressed views that were rather cynical about limited resources

    • “The directorate is financially not quality led”

Symbolism and psychological contracts

  • The thinking of CDs continued to be largely dominated by clinical rather than financial objectives

    • Personal distaste for the style of financial objectives and controls which were becoming dominant

    • ‘Success’ had little to do with meeting financial budgets, but was primarily concerned with meeting contracted numbers of procedures with appropriate quality of patient care

  • ‘I worry that the environment does get more and more financial driven’

  • ‘I feel I...

Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Accounting in the New Public Sector Notes.