Someone recently bought our

students are currently browsing our notes.

X

Abortion Notes

Law Notes > Medical Law Notes

This is an extract of our Abortion document, which we sell as part of our Medical Law Notes collection written by the top tier of Oxford students.

The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our Medical Law Notes. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:

*

Abortion v Contraception - implantation (fertilised egg moves into & attaches itself to the womb) (R (John Smeaton) v Sec of State for Health Legal Status of Foetus

*
Not a person but not nothing either o AG Ref (No3 of 1999) - D stabbed a pregnant woman, baby born but died = manslaughter; foetus not a part of mother - relationship special but one of bond and not identity. Foetus = a sui generis organism

*
No interests warranting legal protection

*
Can't be made a ward of court(ReF (in utero))

*
No rights capable of being protected by others(e.g. father can't seek injunction to prevent abortion in his name)

*
Embryo isn't a person+ has no rights under ECHR o Evans v Amicus - woman not allowed to use b/f's frozen eggs after they've divorced w/out his consent, although otherwise infertile. She had a right under Art 8 to reproduce to be balanced against b/f's right not to. HFE Authority has a reasonable approach to balancing these - not contrary to ECHR b/c legal certainty & need for public confidence in reproductive services justified it. o Vo v France - French law by not providing for offence of unintentional destruction of foetus wasn't contrary ti Art 2 ECHR (right to life) but no clear ruling on legal status of foetus Abortion Law

*
A crim. offence unless Abortion Act 1967 provides a defence

*
Offences (i) S58 OAPA 1861 - administering drugs/using instruments to procure abortion
? can be committed by pregnant woman/someone else w/intent to procure miscarriage (ii) s59 OAPA 1861 - supply of drugs, substances, instruments for unlawful abortion (iii) s1 Infant Life Preservation Act 1929 - any person w/intent to destroy life of child capable of being born (28 weeks, unless proven otherwise) by a wilful act causing him to die b/f he exists independent of his mother

*
Defence
? Necessity - available to doc charged w/carrying out or procuring miscarriage + requires that probable consequence of pregnancy was to make woman a physical or mental wreck

*
Legal Abortion - 4 Requirements (i) Done under authority of registered med practitioner (ii)In NHS hospital/approved place (iii) 2 med practitioners agree on statutory grounds in s1(1)(a) permitting abortion
? Can be 2 different grounds i. Risk to mental & physical health of the woman/her existing kids

*
unless pregnancy post 24 weeks ii. Doc in good faith believes there's risk of grave permanent injury iii. Substantial risk child would suffer physical/mental abnormalities as seriously handicapped

*
No time limit

*
Serious handicap = assisted/dependent performance o Jepson v CC of West Mercia Police- abortion performed by doc b/c foetus suffered from left clip justified b/c no evidence that doc hadn't formed a view in good faith that child would be seriously handicapped
? Must notify relevant authorities of grounds + method used

*
Emergency Abortion (s1(4)) - one doc + doesn't need to be in approved place

*
Conscientious objection by doc/staff (s4)

*
Injunctions by TPs to prevent abortion
? Rare - difficult to get standing, whether claiming in own right or on behalf of foetus
? Challenge brought by AG or CPS + could follow up w/JR o Paton v Trustees of BPAS - father couldn't obtain injunction to prevent abortion +
couldn't claim on behalf of foetus b/c not a legal person & had no standing

*
Incompetent Ps (i) Adults If it's in P's best interests, can abort w/out court order
? Unless med opinion is divided or family strongly opposed (ii) Minors Under 16 - doc can abort w/out parents' consent if P: (a) Gillick competent (b) consented

Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Medical Law Notes.

More Medical Law Samples