Need love - greater than the papacy
'Hear this, O pope, not of all men the holiest but of all men the most sinful! O that God from heaven would soon destroy your throne and sink it into the abyss of hell!'
1518 - met Cajetan in Augsburg Leipzig Debate - summer 1519
1. Extravagant dress
Removed medieval distinction between clergy and laity
Main abuses
Written in German
2. Abuse of eating and drinking
Background Temporal power has no jurisdiction over them
3. Open and common brothels
First wall - spiritual and secular classes
'all Christians are truly of the spiritual estate' 'baptism, gospel and faith alone make us spiritual and a Christian people'
To the Christian Nobility - August 1520 Abolish pilgrimages
God will canonise saints - do not create places of pilgrimage
Priesthood of all believers Three walls
Clerical marriage
Difference between murder of a priest and a peasant
List of issues and solutions Confession to brothers and sisters
Second wall - only pope can interpret Scripture
Abolish festivals - retain Sunday People neglect work and spend money
Third wall - council needs sanction by the pope The Pope
Do not canonise saints
Worldly and ostentatious Abolish begging
Yet they cannot point to a single letter of proof
Praise of the temporal authorities
Reference to the devil
Has not found errors in John Huss's writings Real Antichrist
Only hold one benefice University reform Discard Aristotle
'Since, then, such devilish rule is not only barefaced robbery, deceit and the tyranny of hell's portals, but ruinous to the body and soul of Christendom, it is our duty to exercise all diligence to protect Christendom from such misery and destruction'
Now that Italy is sucked dry, the Romanists are coming into Germany
Evils of Rome
Wolves lying in wait for sheep
Written in Latin Final break with Catholicism
Nearly half on Lord's Supper and Baptism
Discusses engagement, impediments and divorce
Suppressed in Ducal Saxony
Erasmus - 'the breach is irreparable'
The treatise
Wicked and despotic to deny both kinds
Aleander - completely blasphemous
Confirmation, marriage, ordination and extreme unction are not sacraments Nothing in scripture on ordination being a sacrament
1. Withholding cup from the laity
Wanted to show Luther to be a heretic
Translated into German by Thomas Murner
Give grace - why not lesser sign? => why do priests receive both?
3 captivities of the Lord's Supper
Priests are not lords but servants - must administer both kinds
2. Transubstantiation
Lord's Supper
Flesh and blood of Christ
'all of us that have been baptised are equally priests'
3. Sacrifice of the mass
Priesthood of all believers
No mention of this by the holy fathers
Infants partake through faith of the Church
Word of the gospel, not the law
Substance and accidents e.g. red-hot iron =>
transaccidentation
The Babylonian Captivity of the Church - October 1520
'we are all equally priests' - same power in respect to the Word and the sacraments
Sign - memorial or remembrance of his promise Nature of sacraments
Have abolished it
word + sign Divine promise and faith
Contrition as a work and merit - not faith Faith Confession is necessary and commanded of God
Penance Does not desire or need works
Mystery or secret thing received by the faith of the heart
Confess to brothers and sisters Receive mass, give prayer Not 7 sacraments - baptism, penance and the bread Absolution should follow satisfaction
Christ's testament Death
Should have one single sacrament - 3 sacramental signs
Very few remember baptism or glory in it Promise Divine promise - belief and baptism => saved (Mark 16:16)
Baptism
All sacraments are to nourish faith Signifies death and resurrection
Infants are aided by the faith of others
Power consists in the words of Christ
Good work
Not a good work - cannot commune for someone else
'It is you Romans who are the heretics and godless schismatics, for you presume upon your figments alone against the clear Scriptures of God'
Not a sacrifice Against vows - faith alone Require faith and grace
Cannot be proved from scripture
Should not judge others - edifying love Glories of the Christian life are not preached about or sought after
After Leipzig Debate - returned to Wittenberg and wrote a lot
A Christian lives not in himself, but in Christ and in his neighbour
Conciliatory spirit Unyielding, stubborn ceremonialists
2 classes of men
Simple-minded, ignorant men - weak in the faith
Miltitz wanted to prevent a rift in the Church
Background
First published in German - yet also in Latin Must discipline his body Leo as a lamb in the midst of wolves
- Babylon of the Roman Curia
The Freedom of a Christian - November 1520
Subject it to the Spirit
Eck was the Devil's servant
Outer man
Works - done only to please God
Importance+
of+inner+man
A Christian is a perfectly free lord of all, subject to none
Builder and house analogy
Can be misinterpreted
Priesthood of all believers
Good works do not make a good man but a good man does good works
A Christian is a perfectly dutiful servant of all, subject to all
Trees exist before their fruits Twofold nature of man - spiritual and bodily Works cannot glorify God Not works, only faith
Comfort
Promise of God - believe in Christ
'One thing, and only one thing, is necessary for Christian life, righteousness and freedom. That one thing is the most holy Word of God, the gospel of Christ'
Only thing necessary for the soul
31powers1of1faith: Christ's1atonement181no1need1for1works Promises1of1New1Testament Wedding1ring1of1faith
Commandments => realise our helplessness
Faith unites soul with Christ - wedding ring Teaches us inwardly though the living instruction of his Spirit
'we are also priests forever'
Ceremonies are the test of the righteousness of faith
10 directors must constantly investigate state of the poor
Appoint pastor
Wants)decline)in) existing)foundations
Household preaching
Monkery)1)harmful) error)and)deception Preface Annual contribution
Let)them)dwindle) away)or)help)them) to)disappear
Provisions Distributed amongst poor
2 barrels for foodstuffs
Box for coins
Governing)authorities) should)take)over) property
Common chest
2 nobility 2 council 3 town citizens 3 rural peasantry
3.)Common)chest)1) gifts)to)the)needy
Schoolmaster for boys
10 elected trustees
1.)Provision)for)inmates
2.)Funds)for)new)start)in)life
Ordinance)of)a) Common)Chest)1) Leisnig,)1523
No begging
Mendicant)houses)=>)schools
Solicitation of alms
Common)Chest)1)less)evils
1.)Begging
2.)Misuse)of)the)ban
Also instruct girls under 12
Pastor - Word of God
All have own keys General assembly 3 times a year
Key ideas
No toleration for begging
Support for old and ill
3.)Zinss%contract
Avoid drink, fornication, gambling etc.
Universal priesthood - rights to parish property
Used)to)be)called) bona%ecclesiae%1) common)property
Archbishop - secular pomp Obligated to wage war against the Turks - vengeance for pillage and murder
Choice to refuse evil and do good
Weak and miserable without God Instituted by God
Hindered by the devil
Marriage
'No attention is paid to how one teaches, or believes, loves, how one lives a Christian life, how to care for the poor, how one comforts the weak, or punishes the unruly and whatever else belongs to such an office'
Bishop means supervisor or visitor Other rules on the Christian Ban and the teaching of children
Free Will
Not obligated to teach and rule in spiritual affairs
Preface Appeal to John, Duke of Saxony
No divorce
Obligated to order things so that rebellion does not arise amongst subjects
Keep some holy days Divides up teaching the gospel
The Doctrine Sin to dishonour sacrament True repentance Promise of righteousness and eternal life - remission of sin
Examination before the sacrament
Instructions*for*visitors*of*parish*
priests*in*Electoral*Saxony
Should be taught the difference between church order and secular government
Preach the whole Gospel
The Ten Commandments
3. Teach reason for the use of the sacrament
Fear God and show contrition Sacrament of the Body and Blood of the Lord
2. Both kinds Unless weak Christians
Elements of the Christian life
Use German where most do not understand Latin
1. True body and blood of Christ
10 Commandments
- teach good works
Sinful not to pray For both spiritual and temporal things
True Christian Prayer
Children are to be baptised
Keep Sabbath holy
Should be grateful preserves peace e.g. grateful for saving child
Obey government
2. Faith that sins will be forgiven True Christian Penance Still obedient to harsh government
1. Need true contrition and terror before God
2. Faith => forgiveness of sins and righteousness
3. Good works
Poverty
Illness
Hear Word of God
Should not use sword without government authority - live by the sword, die by the sword
1. Repentance / contrition
All tribulation is from God
In German Not just for children reminds others to repent
Fear judgement of God
Tribulation
Baptism Honour parents
Preach repentance and forgiveness of sins
Water - penitence, contrition and sorrow
Children
'each tribulation washes away sin, if its pain is endured in faith'
Written&in&October&1520&5&
after&Exsurge&domine Still&identified&with&
Luther's&reform&work
Background
Temptation - test and proof of our faith
Imitatio'Christi&5&
Thomas&a&Kempis Suffering
New&ideas&and&influences Late&medieval&
mysticism
'all suffering is a punishing rod with which the heavenly Father visits, cleanses and beautifies his children'
Gelassenheit
Widely&used Anabaptists&5&
'existentialist'&commitment&
to&divine&will&=>&
abandonment&of&
externalities
Better to have death of flesh and life of spirit
Carlstadt&focuses&on&physical&and&
spiritual&suffering&5&self5emptying&
or&self5denial&before&the&divine
Rejoice in suffering
Faith dependent upon it
Tract&on&the&Supreme&Virtue&
of&Gelassenheit&5&1520
Take up the cross - suffering, mockery, ridicule, death and destruction
Word of God
Bible - so clear that a layman can understand it
'I know that there is no greater virtue on earth and in heaven than detachment, when a person leaves behind all possessions, honour, friends, body and soul' Christ - 'I have come to send a sword - a sword which separates children from their parents'
Places detachment ahead of works and suffering
'I will willingly divest myself of my archdeaconate and all the goods which I have; forgive father, mother, brothers and sisters; and surrender [Gelassen] everything in body and soul which draws me away and distances me from divine promises. I know that I must be yielded [Gelassen]
and that I must let go [Gelassen] of all creatures and that I must not trust any angel who wishes to teach and bless me other than as delineated in the Bible'
Otherwise devil will find you
Scripture is the sword
Must be accomplished with suffering, blood and death
e.g. Hus
1. Images are wrong against 1st commandment (no other gods before me)
2. Carved or painted idols on altars are even worse
3. Necessary to do away with them - give reasons from Scripture
Should prevent begging and forestall hunger
Show that there are not Christians in the town
Removal of Images Images are an abomination
Concerning Beggars
We attribute holiness to images - call them saints
Give them a trade or job Deuteronomy - you are to destroy altars and smash images
Cloisters are wicked
Monks and nuns should leave monasteries
Appearance and external signs of God Falsehood of images
On the Removal of Images and That There Should Be No Beggars Among Christians - 1522
Church income and interest
Authorities should have done this
Heart is far from God
Crucifixion - only see physical suffering
Common box
Laity
Exodus 20:3 - 'You shall have no other gods before me'
Christ says the spirit gives life
'It cannot be true therefore that images are the textbooks of lay persons. For they are unable to learn their salvation from them'
'Without the power of Christ, no one will be saved; but without the physical form of Christ, many thousands shall be saved in days to come'
Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Luther and the German Reformation Notes.