Tax
Type of tax | Individual/Corp? | Seller/Buyer? | Share/Asset? |
|---|---|---|---|
Corp tax on trading profits | Corp | Seller | Share or Asset |
Corp tax on chargeable gains | Corp | Seller | Share or Asset |
Income Tax | Individual | Seller | Share or Asset |
CGT | Individual | Seller | Share or Asset |
VAT | Individual or Corp | Seller or Buyer | Business (TOGC) |
Stamp Duty | Individual or Corp | Buyer | Share |
SDLT | Individual or Corp | Buyer | Share or Asset |
[SDLT clawback] | Individual or Corp | Target (indirectly B) | Share or Asset |
De-grouping charges | Corp | Seller | Share |
Structure for approaching tax q:
is scenario share sale or business sale?
who is receiving cons/is prima facie chargeable for tax?
what tax(es) will be payable?
how is it/are they calculated? (nb. you won’t actually have to calculate but useful notionally)
are there any exemptions or reliefs (ie. can any tax be mitigated/ reduced/ extinguished?)
apply any test(s) relevant to exemptions or reliefs to the facts
Conclude whether the exemption or relief applies on the facts
Share sales
By corporate Seller:
Answers to (1) and (2) are clearly share sale and corporate chargeable for tax.
Main tax will always be corporation tax.
Tax will be calculated on the chargeable gain made on the disposal of shares
Exemptions
‘SSE’ - Substantial Shareholding Exemption | Main one - v imp: 3 x conds
... Then no tax payable on sale of shares |
Tax deferral on share-for-paper exchange | If SSE not available, this may be if cons is in form of paper 2 x conds
Where paper is loan notes there is another non-stat cond that:
|
Effects of tax deferral | |
| S’s tax liability on the sale of T shares is effectively postponed until S sells the shares it has been issued in the B. S’s chargeable gain (or loss) for tax purposes is calculated as the amount if originally paid for T and the amount for which it sells shares in B. Value of T shares on date of actual transfer is therefore irrelevant. Sum = Amount it makes selling B shares minus amount originally paid for T Nb. S will only accept shares as cons from B if B is listed co as that means its shares will be freely marketable |
| The tax on any gain is deferred until the loan notes are redeemend, sold or otherwise disposed of. Where shares are sold in exchange for LNs, the tax liability arising on the original shares is just held in suspense until the LNs are redeemed, sold or otherwise disposed of. This type of deferral (as it is different to shares) is known as holdover. The amount of tax on the gain is never reduced (ie. If a S bought a building for 300 and sold it for 350 of LNs to a B, when the S redeems his LNs he will owe corp tax on his chargeable gain on 50). Nb. if S accepts cons in form of LNs, it should require LNs to be supported by a guarantee from a bank (or listed part co of the B) or by security over B’s assets. |
| SSE and share-for-paper exchange | If SSE is satisfied, even if cons is in paper form there will be no chargeable gain for tax purposes. Therefore SSE is most desirable exemption as w/share-for-paper S is still paying tax just deferring it. |
| Pre sale dividend | If a T declares a pre sale div it will strip the T of value and therefore reduce chargeable gain for S. Generally, there is no tax payable on a dividend to a UK co. |
Apply to facts
Conclude
By individual Seller
As above, (1) and (2)
relevant tax = Capital Gains Tax
calculated on chargeable gain on 1 million
Exemptions
ER’ - Entrepreneur's Relief | Tax rate of 10% applies on chargeable up to a 10 mill cumulative lifetime amount if:
|
Tax deferral on share-for-paper exchange | Also available for individuals |
Pre-sale dividends vs ER/CGT | see if ER is available - if yes, always preferable Otherwise calculate whether appropriate dividend tax rate is less than CGT for that tax bracket then conclude nb. remember w/divs you need to gross up Generally for pre-sale divs vs CGT: additional = bad idea, higher rate = good idea, basic rate = good idea |
For buyer (corp or individual)
Sale is of shares (1) and either an corp/individual buyer (2)
relevant taxes are Stamp Duty, VAT and SDLT clawback
Stamp Duty | current rate is 0.5% unless transaction <1000 |
[VAT | exempt supply for VAT purposes] |
SDLT clawback | can arise where T received land as a result of intra-group transfer and leaves group w/in 3 yr of receipt of that land |
calculated on the facts
Exemptions - generally indemnities and warranties (used to flush out info)
apply facts
conclude
Asset Sale
Tax liabilities of T remain w/S so B is not concerned re finding out re any hidden tax liabilities
For corporate S:
Business sale (1) and corp S (2)
relevant corp tax is either
income receipts/trading profits | trading stock IP and goodwill (post April 2002) |
capital receipts/chargeable gain | IP and goodwill (pre April 2002) Land & property Plant & Machinery |
calculated accordingly - both types are combined to create Total Taxable Profits (‘TTP’) and corp tax is paid on total sum
exemptions
Trading profits | balancing allowances (if T sold for less than tax written down value (‘TWDV’) a balancing (which can be a loss and used accordingly) |
Chargeable gains | indexation capital losses (T? group?) Rollover relief on replacement of business assets - defers tax but T will need to acquiring more capital assets for this to apply |
Both/overlap | trading losses (T? group?) |
Apply any tests
Conclude
Passing proceeds of sale to s’ers can cause an issue as on a bus sale this will lead to double taxation (once in hands of S co and once in hands of S co s’ers). Tax consequence will depend on if S co s’ers are co’s or individuals
S co w/corp s’ers |
|
S co w/individual s’ers |
|
For B
Business sale (1) and buyer (2)
applicable types of tax:
Corp tax | B doesn’t inherit S’s tax liabilities therefore won’t be concerned in S’s base cost in relation to assets |
Income generating assets | The price allocated to trading stock, work in progress, IP and goodwill can be deducted when calculating B’s income profits |
Capital allowances | B can claim capital allowances in respect of qualifying assets such as P&M and price allocated in business sale agreement will form basis of B’s capital allowances |
VAT | GR - ‘taxable person’ making taxable supplies of goods or service in the course of this business must pay VAT to the recipient of those supplies and account for this VAT to HMRC [see exception below] |
| SDLT | payable if B is acquiring land |
calculated as appropriate
Exemptions
Rollover Relief on replacement of business assets | A B who has disposed of qualifying assets for purposes of ROR on replacement of business assets w/in period of 3 yrs prior to business acquisition, or who plans to make such a disposal in yr following acquisition may be able to over gain of that disposal into the base cost of any qualifying asset it purchases |
VAT ‘TOGC’ exception | no VAT applies where there is Transfer Of a Going Concern (TOGC) To qualify:
When business assets include land, there is an additional requirement. A Ld can make an election to waive exemption on a particular property and charge VAT on rent - turning an exempt supply into a standard rated supply. The B must check to see if S has made an election to waive exemption. If S has made such an election, B must make the same election in relation to property on or before completion otherwise will not be see as ‘same kind of business w/no significant break’ in the eyes of HMRC and condition (1) will not be satisfied. |
apply to facts
conclude
Group co taxation
Remember in UK there are a number of tax reliefs...