PPE Notes Sociological Theory Notes
Notes on ideology, class, and methodology. Including summaries of Bourdieu, Durkheim, Weber, Zizek, Marx and Giddens....
The following is a more accessible plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our Sociological Theory Notes. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:
Sylvia Walby - Theorising Patriarchy (1989)
Introduction
Patriarchy and capitalism are analytically independent
Patriarchy can be modelled in terms of several partially interdependent structures
Definition
Definitions of patriarchy differ
it has been used to describe relations in which men dominate both women and younger generations of men
this is a mistake because it implies a theory of gender inequality in which men’s domination of other men is central in men’s domination of women
Patriarchy can preliminarily be defined as ‘a system of social structures, and practices in which men dominate, oppress and exploit women’
‘structures’ allows for the fact that not all men are in dominate positions, and likewise not all women are dominated
Patriarchy exists primarily as a set of social relations, then as a set of structures, then as a set of practices
Dual Systems Analysis
Patriarchy pre-dates and post-dates capitalism, and hence cannot be derived from it (likewise racism)
Hence we need a dual or triple systems analysis, in terms of capitalism, patriarchy and racism
Are the different parts seen as fused into one system of capitalist racist patriarchy, or as analytically distinct categories?
distinct
Hartmann’s analysis, though ostensibly retaining distinctness, underestimates the tension between capitalism and patriarchy
The conflicts of patriarchal and capitalist interests do not have an inevitable result, but are based on local factors in patriarchal and capitalist relations
Ahistoricism, Universalism and Diversity
Can patriarchy deal with different forms of gender inequality at different times and places?
e.g. experiences of black women are very different to those of white women - for black women the family is not a theatre of domination, but a relief from racist domination
‘We need a concept of patriarchy which is flexible enough to capture the variation in women’s experience and inequality between women.’
Is a concept of patriarchy essentialist in defining ‘woman’ etc? Does this view the place of women as static?
often feminist writing does take one factor as the critical base of patriarchy, creating a universalist and ahistoric theory
but even where feminist theory is like this, its empirical findings show variation in patriarchal relations
clearly there is a diversity of key structures and practices with causal primacy in gender relations
the family
sexuality
men’s violence
politics and the state
Structures
There are six man patriarchal structures that together constitute a system of patriarchy:
patriarchal mode of production (expropriation of women’s labour)
patriarchal relations within waged labour
patriarchal state
male violence
patriarchal relations in sexuality
patriarchal culture
these have considerable duration over time and space
The Patriarchal Mode of Production
Women’s labour is expropriated by their husbands within the marriage and household relationship
the product of a wife’s labour is labour power - that of her, her husband and her children. Yet the husband expropriates her labour because he possesses the labour power she produces, and can sell it as if it were his own
Is it to women’s disadvantage? They may enjoy it, it may be better than the alternative etc. It may provide the basis for solidarity in class or race struggle. Hence the family may be in the woman’s interests
yes, it is, but this is because the patriarchal system necessitates marriage for security etc
this counter argument presupposes the primacy of class or ethnic exploitation over patriarchal exploitation
Patriarchal Relations in Paid Work
Key element is the closure of access by men against women
occupational segregation - lower wages, jobs with lower status for women
types of segregation:
vertical
horizontal
full-timers/part-timers
skilled/unskilled
this particular configuration cannot be understood outside the relationship between patriarchy and capitalist production relations
Patriarchal State
Women are excluded from the...
Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Sociological Theory Notes.
Notes on ideology, class, and methodology. Including summaries of Bourdieu, Durkheim, Weber, Zizek, Marx and Giddens....
Ask questions 🙋 Get answers 📔 It's simple 👁️👄👁️
Our AI is educated by the highest scoring students across all subjects and schools. Join hundreds of your peers today.
Get Started