Introduction to Amnesia
Patient H.M. – Scoville & Milner(1957)
Long history of major + minor seizures + uncontrollable by multiple forms of medication – intractable epilepsy
Radical bilateral medial temporal lobe resection
After – incidence + severity of seizures dramatically reduced
Anterograde memory almost entirely absent + some retrograde loss
His RA extended approx. between 3+ 11 yrs
Measuring Anterograde Amnesia (AA)
Wechsler Memory scale personal + current info/ mental control (recite alphabet etc) / logical memory (recall short story)/digit span/paired associate learning/visual reproduction – rey osterrieth figure - draw from memory (potentially dissociable)
HM memory quotient = 67 – v. deficient
Rivermead behavioural memory test practical test of everyday memory
Remembering – name from photo/hidden belonging
Recognition – 10 line drawings over 5 mins / 10 faces over 5mins
Measuring Retrograde Amnesia (RA)
Test for public events + famous faces over diff time periods – before onset of amnesia – uncover the extent of the temporal gradient e.g. Squire et al (1989)
Autobiographical Memory Interview (AMI)
Assesses recall of facts from person’s life (personal semantic) – standardised e.g. school
Recall of specific incidents in patients life – episodic – verified by family
Assesses 3 broad time spans : childhood/early adult life/recent facts + incidents enables you to gauge the temporal gradient
Advantantages easy to administer / not dependent on level of patient interest in current affairs / does not require regular updating BUT - difficult to know the accuracy of incidents
Spared abilities in amnesia
Intellectual abilities – speech + IQ
STM/WM
Baddeley & Warrington (1970) – compared performance of amnesic patients + control ptp’s on immediate and delayed free recall
Peterson short term forgetting task, paired associate learning , digit span , Hebb digit sequence technique
Amnesic ptp’s have normal STM but defective LTM
Conditioning
Warrington & Weitkrantz – conditioned eye blink responses in 2 severe amnesics – tone and puff of air conditioned an eye blink in them
Priming
Warrington & Weizkrantz (1970) Gollins incomplete pictures test – line/dot to dot drawings – increasing to full drawings – remember
Primed and then tested an hour later –could not explicitly remember the image
Repetition priming – Graf et al. (1984)
First shown full list of words
Free recall / cued recall – complete with word from study list / word stem completion with first word come to mind
Compare free recall to word stem completion – priming effect
Amnesic poor fee recall – but better than controls on word completion therefore they do remember in a sense
Tower of Hanoi (Cohen, 1984)
Get start position – then target position – have to move the 3 blocks around to get desired pattern
Amnesics improve over time – normal pattern – no memory of completing task
How do you explain these spared abilities?
May be skills gained early in life
Other memory systems affected – taxonomy of memory – Tulving
Amnesics good non-declarative memory BUT bad declarative
Is that restricted to episodic or semantic as well ?
Can amnesics learn new semantic info?
HM used a 1950’s vocabulary – it failed to update – could not define new bords such as biodegradable attempts to teach him 8 new words failed (Gabrieli, Cohen & Corkin, 1983)
Kitchner et al (1998) case study densly amnesic patient can remember some recent famous faces, + can define somerecently introduced vocab + knowledge of recent events BUT did not acquire semantic info in the normal fashion – slow + laborious – man repetitions - maybe deficit in EM impacting SM (e.g. remember where you were when something happened etc)
Some semantic knowledge can be acquired in the absence of EM
But many patients have impairments in acquiring both EM + SM
Semantic problems may remain unnoticeable in adults – as little semantic info is learned in adulthood
EM + SM deficits don’t nec have to co-occur – but they usually do
Developmental Amnesia
Vargha-Khadem et al (1997)
3 patients with amnesia resulting from early events
Profound amnesia for episodic materials
Still progressing through school – normal IQ + ACADEMIC ACHEIVEMENT
Able to comprehend passages + could acquire knowledge about the world
Seems semantic memory can develop in the absence of EM
SM may develop normally in developmental amnesia – may be an adaptive thing able to cope + adapt – but adults have more difficulties in SM due to EM impairments – more reliant on EM to form SM whereas children adopt coping strategies
Dissociation of Epidosic Memory + Semantic Memory in childhood amnesia: (Vicari et al, 2007)
C.L 8 yr old child, surgical removal of an ependymoma from left cerebral ventricle at 4yrs
Found patient who despite being impaired on ability to recollect new episodic info –still demonstrates preserved abilities to acquire new semantic knowledge
Suggests that neural circuits implicated in the memorisation of autobiographical events + factual info, do not overlap completely
Functional dissociations in healthy subjects +...