Insurance Warranties Notes

Insurance Warranties

In insurance law contractual provisions are defined by their functional effect. Insurance warranties have the most significant effect on the cover afforded to the policy holder.

What? An ‘insurance warranty’ is an obligation entered into by the insured which must be complied with exactly, whether or not it is material to the risk. It is effectively a condition precedent to insurers having a liability to provide an indemnity at all in future under the insurance contract.

I.e. It is a promise by the insured as to the past, current or future existence of a particular state of affairs so that the insurer’s obligation to indemnify the insured is ‘conditional’ on the fulfilment of that promise.

An insurance warranty is an obligation entered into by the insured which must be complied with exactly as it is. Very draconian.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Effect of Breach

• S.33(3) MIA: Expressly states that the insurer is discharged from liability if the insured breaches the insurance warranty. HH Casualty makes clear that this applies to both marine and non-marine insurance.

• The Goodluck; Effects: The insurance contract continues and the insured must continue to pay premiums but insurers have no further liability to indemnity under the policy. UWs are discharged from liability from the moment of the insured’s breach, but are still liable for earlier pre-breach claims.

There does not need to be any causative link between breach of warranty and the loss the insured suffers. This is considered harsh.

No election must be made by the insurers. They are automatically discharged from liability and the insured breaches the insurance warranty.

• S.34(2) MIA: Once the insurance warranty has been broken the insured cannot rely on the defence that the breach was remedied and the warranty actually complied with before the loss.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

When might a breach of warranty have no such effect?

1) Change of circumstances so the warranty becomes obsolete (s.34(1) MIA).

E.g. The insured owns several properties and warrants to ensure adequate safety precautions for them all, but sells one off so he no longer has an insurable interest in it. Then the warranty is inapplicable.

2) Waiver of the breach by the insured (s.34(3) MIA). UWs could waive by:

• Carrying on as before and accepting some extra performance / premium from the insured. This would be done by agreement.

• Estopped from relying on breach of warranty if the insurer conducts themselves in a way the insured is objectively entitled to treat as a representation that, despite the breach, UWs will still pay an indemnity and the insured relies on that to their detriment. The insurer must have knowledge.

E.g. If the insured sends an email to the insurer telling them they sailed their ship into a prohibited area and asking them if their insurance cover has been stopped. If the insurer does not send a response then that representation implies that insurance cover continues.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Types of Warranties

Warranties are usually given as to:

1. Prior or existing...

Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Insurance Law Notes.