Someone recently bought our

students are currently browsing our notes.

X

The Concept Of Consideration Notes

Law Notes > Contract Law Notes

This is an extract of our The Concept Of Consideration document, which we sell as part of our Contract Law Notes collection written by the top tier of Oxford students.

The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our Contract Law Notes. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:

Should the consideration doctrine remain?
Justifications

*
o o o

*
o o

*
o

*
o

o

*

Chen Wishart: Evidence of existence and seriousness of undertaking Consideration = evidentiary role, is "valuable signal" to show undertaking Looks at which undertakings are enforceable rather than who can enforce Problems:
? McKendrick: existence of deeds mean that no consideration required at all sometimes

*
But Me: But in such cases, we have the written deed which provides evidence of the promise made and what the promise was for. o Consideration serves an evidentiary purpose without which oral contracts
? McKendrick: Consideration need not be adequate e.g. PS1 for Football Club (cos you're actually buying the debt they're in)

*
PS1 doesn't really reflect "seriousness of undertaking".

*
BUT it is a clear indication that the contract is meant to be enforceable - often used as a lawyer device, parties may not even know about it and it may not be paid o so yes it is artificial, but has a clear evidential value - some other declaration would have to get involved otherwise.
? 3. Couldn't we just infer this from the surrounding circumstances?

*
Possibly, but not as quick and easy for the court to see o Equally, meant to be an objective concept, and we may very well get involved in a debate of the subjective views of the parties about whether it was enforceable or not Chen Wishart: Intuitive justice of exchange Enforceability of bargain reflects idea of reciprocity which reflects the norm between equals in social arrangements and symbolises difference between trading and talking Stevens: Force behind consideration = maxim that "equity will not assist the volunteer"
? Deed much easier to be set aside as a "mistake" rather than a contract with good consideration Chen Wishart: Explains measure of relief Bargain model explains extent of liability for breach of contract
? Expectation measure gives promise value of performed contract because he has given the agreed equivalence of that performance. Raz: marks boundary of appropriate legal involvement Contract law facilitates institution
? We can facilitate agreements between friends owing to trust and social sanctions
? Much harder to do that with strangers

*
Use of contract law viz. consideration helps to bridge that gap of trust Collins: consideration draws line between public enforceable transactions and private unenforceable agreements. Collins: distinction between gift and contract

Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Contract Law Notes.

More Contract Law Samples