This is an extract of our Restrictive Covenants document, which we sell as part of our Land Law Notes collection written by the top tier of Oxford students.
The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our Land Law Notes. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:
Restrictive Covenants Requirements for restrictive covenants
Need for a dominant tenement
Need for restrictive covenant to touch and concern dominant tenement o Smith: essentially question of fact = has the land been benefited by the restrictive covenant? Courts will be wide in applying this. o Wrotham Park Estate v Parkside Homes :
? Brightman J:
The burden of a covenants is enforceable if: o The covenant was entered into for the benefit of the land of the covenantee o The land restricted is sufficiently defined or ascertained. o The restriction is such that an estate owner may reasonably take the view that the restriction remains of value to his estate. o London CC v Allen :
? Sedley LJ: you need land that can be benefitted by the burden if you wish to enforce the burden
If you've disposed of any land near to covenantee's land o Then you cannot enforce the covenant. o But three issues remain:
? Large Estates
Can a very large estate be said to benefit from a covenant taken on the sale of a small part?
o Probably so long as reasonable
Smith: today, more likely that covenant provide benefit for part of the estate rather than estate as a whole unit o Ergo, if far away part of estate from covenanted land sold off, purchaser of far away part less likely to be held able to enforce covenant.
? Types of Covenant
Covenant not to build or covenant not to change use of land is fine o But what about where covenants designed to prevent competition with covenantee's business on neighbouring land?
? Hemmingway Securities Ltd v Dunraven Ltd
? How far apart?
If covenantee owns properties some distance apart and attempts to impose restrictive covenant on the sale of one of them
Smith: courts probably sympathetic, but long distances may lead to trouble.
Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Land Law Notes.