Remedies In Tort Notes

REMEDIES IN TORT

FACTORS TO BEAR IN MIND WHEN DECIDING ON A REMEDY

• ADR?

• cost / benefit - if loss minimal, will cost outweigh benefit?

• can D pay damages if awarded?

• does C need immediate remedy: interim injunction / interim payment

LIABILITY

Elements of tort

Causation

• factual causation

  • general rule: but for test

• legal causation

  • NAI, the more foreseeable, the less likely to break the chain

  • sometimes considered part of remoteness - D only liable up to point chain breaks

Remoteness

• non-intentional torts

  • the Wagon Mound

    • foreseeability (slight likelihood) of the particular kind of damage

    • if kind of damage foreseeable, full extent recoverable

  • scope of duty - SAAMCO defence

    • even if damage is foreseeable, NOT recoverable if outside scope of DOC owed to C

    • sometimes seen as part of principle of DOC

• intentional torts

  • directness: tortfeasor liable for all consequences of tort, even though NOT reasonably foreseeable

  • applies to:

    • deceit ref: misrep

    • trespass

    • harassment

Egg shell rules

• egg shell skull

  • D takes V as finds them

• egg shell bank balance

  • if C's loss exacerbated by his impecuniosity (+ inability to mitigate), still recoverable (provided reasonably foreseeable)

PROOF OF LOSS + DAMAGE

• C must prove:

  • fact of loss

  • NOT extent of loss (court will assess, difficulty of assessment no bar to recovery)

• trespass to land: C does NOT need to prove loss

QUANTUM OF COMPENSATORY DAMAGES

Nature of damages

• = compensatory - put C in position would have been in had the tort NOT occurred

Time of assessment

• when damage occurred (usually accrual)

• BUT court has discretion AND likely to exercise in:

  • PI + death - date of trial

  • repair to property - date reasonable for C to make repairs

Types of loss recoverable and mode of assessment

1. PI AND economic loss consequent on PI ref: PI

2. property damage AND loss consequent on property damage

   • cost of repair / replacement OR diminution in value (goods irreplaceable / uneconomic to repair e.g. car write off) - common sense, same principles as contract

   • profit earning property:

     • cost of cure + loss of profit; OR

     • diminution in value (includes profit earning potential)

   • negligent over-valuation of purchased property: diminution in value

3. interference with property AND loss consequent

   • permanently deprived: cost of repair / replacement OR diminution in value

   • temporarily deprived: loss of use

   • loss of amenity

4. interference with land AND loss consequent

   • trespass to land

     • DON'T need proof of loss (actionable per se)

     • financial loss arising from loss of use OR fair rent value OR fair easement value

   • nuisance

     • = tort against land itself (NOT person)

     • losses must be referable to effect on land itself

     • heads of loss:

       • physical damage to land itself

       • loss consequent on physical damage to land

       • loss of amenity (diminution of amenity value of land):

         • temporary / permanent devaluation of land; OR

         • SPD (NO diminution in value of land)

     • remedies

       • damages

       • injunction OR damages in lieu

5. other kinds of personal non-financial damage

   1. loss of liberty

   2. mental distress

   • that amounts to suffering = PI

   • falling short of suffering = prima facie NOT recoverable, tacked on to intentional torts

   3. reputation - usually from defamation

   4. inconvenience + discomfort - separate head if NO overlap with loss of amenity; usually modest

6. damages under HRA

   • 'just and appropriate' - usually modest

   • ECHR = benchmark

Types of loss NOT recoverable

1. pure economic loss

1. general rule: CAN'T recover

2. exceptions:

   • negligent misstatement

   • deceit

   • slander etc.

   • loss of chance

2. cost of remedying defective premises

3. consequential economic loss

   • C must have legal OR beneficial interest in property damaged

QUANTUM OF NON-COMPENSATORY DAMAGES

Nominal damages

• torts actionable per se where there is no actual loss

Exemplary / punitive damages

• recoverable in 3 situations

1. oppressive, arbitrary, unconstitutional action by govt servants

2. D's conduct calculated to make profit

3. statute sanctions

• NOT recoverable for: negligence, public nuisance, breach of statutory duty, deceit

• quantum = discretion of judge / jury (taking into account D's means)

Aggravated damages

• for injury to feelings, caused by malice

• academic debate as to whether compensatory or not - usually part of C's general damages

REDUCTION OF DAMAGES

Duty to mitigate

...

Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our BPTC Civil Ligitation Notes.