This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more

BPTC Law Notes BPTC Civil Ligitation Notes

Track Allocation Disclosure Inspection Notes

Updated Track Allocation Disclosure Inspection Notes

BPTC Civil Ligitation Notes

BPTC Civil Ligitation

Approximately 1172 pages

A collection of the best BPTC notes the director of Oxbridge Notes (an Oxford law graduate) could find after combing through dozens of samples from outstanding students with the highest results in England and carefully evaluating each on accuracy, formatting, logical structure, spelling/grammar, conciseness and "wow-factor".

In short, these are what we believe to be the strongest set of BPTC notes available in the UK this year. This collection of BPTC notes is fully updated for recent exams, ...

Available here

The following is a more accessible plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our BPTC Civil Ligitation Notes. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:

Track Allocation

Track Allocation

There are three tracks:

  1. Small Claims Track ("SCT")

  2. Fast Track ("FT")

  3. Multi-Track Claims ("MCT")

When is track decided?

  • After D files DS per r26.3.

    • If more than one defendant, allocation will be determined when:

      • All Ds have filed their DS; or

      • When period for filing last DS has expired, whichever is sooner. (r26.3(2))

    • If a claim is referred to Small Claims Mediation Service under r26.4A but has not been notified of any settlement, the court will presume the case is continuing and allocate within 4 weeks from the date on which the last DQ is filed (r26.5(2A) and PD263A.1.)

The Court Officer will provisionally allocate the claim and will serve Notice of Proposed Allocation on each party requiring parties to file & serve completed DQ per r26.3.

  • Applications for strike out/summary judgment should be made before or when filing DS. Track dealt with after hearing his application.

  • Court can dispense with need for DQ - PD26(2.4).

  • The Court will allocate to track after DQ is received unless stayed (eg: for Mediation) per r26.5.

  • Court may hold Allocation Hearing if it thinks necessary r26.5(4) PD26(6.1) - 7 days notice will be given.

  • Court may subsequently reallocate (r26.10)

What is contained in the DQ?

  • Parties must consult one another and cooperate (PD26(2.3)(1));

  • Parties must seek to agree CMC Directions (PD26(2.3));

  • All Directions for FT must be based on Pt 28.

  • All Directions for MTC are on the website.

Factors Governing Track Allocation:

r26.8 specifies the following factors:

  • Financial Value of claim in dispute;

    • It is for court to determine. When valuing, the court must disregard:

    • Any amount not in dispute;

    • Any claim for interest, costs, contributory negligence (r26.8(2)(d)).

    • Court may order C to justify the amount if it feels C has exaggerated his claim (PD26(7.3))

  • Nature of remedy;

  • Complexity;

  • Number of Parties;

  • Value of counterclaim/Pt 20 and complexity;

  • Amount of oral evidence required;

  • Important of claim to non-parties;

  • Views expressed by parties;

    • Parties views are important, but decision is for court.

    • Prior to 1 April 2013, parties' views were binding. (Old r26.7(3)).

  • Circumstances of parties;

If 2+ Cs started against same D with same CF, and each has a claim against D separate from other C, court will consider claim of each C separately. (r26.8(3)).

Differences between Tracks

Small Claims Track Fast Track Multi-Track Claims
Limits

r27.1(2):

PI Claims valued <10,000 and PSLA damages are <1,000.

LL/T breach of repair obligations where work is <1,000.

Any other claim <10,000 excluding harassment or unlawful eviction.

Dishonesty allegations are not suitable for SCT, or genuine disputes over amount which cannot be dealt with at disposal hearing.

<25,000 after 2009

<15,000 before 2009

AND

Expert Evidence limited to 1 expert per party and expert evidence in two expert fields.

r26.7(3) - If over 25,000, court cannot allocate to FT unless:

  1. All parties agree;

So usually, 10-25,000

Any other claim.

Claims for less than 100,000 will usually be transferred to CC unless falls within HC's jurisdiction.
Judge DJ (PD27(1)). Only CJ's with their consent (PD27(11.2)). DJs and CJs.

CC/HC Judge.

CMCs can be dealt with by DJ/CJ.
Length of Hearing 30 mins 1 day (defined as 5 hours: 10:30am-1pm, 2pm-4:30pm) Can be less than 1 day if sufficiently complex, but generally longer.
Features

r27.8 Hearing is "fair":

  • Informal; (can be in court, or "round a table")

  • No preliminary hearing unless (i) needed to ensure fair hearing and necessary for party to attend court to understand special directions; (ii) Do give summary judgment ("No real prospects") or (iii) Strike out ("No reasonable grounds") (r27.6; 14 days notice will be given (r27.6(3))

  • No strict rules of evidence;

  • Permission needed for expert evidence r27.5. It is limited. Up to 750 of the expert's fee is recoverable per r27.14(2)(f) PD(7.3)(2).

  • Court fees are less.

  • No-little legal aid available.

  • No evidence needed on oath;

  • May limit XX;

  • MUST give reasons for decision.

  • PD27(5) - Hearing will be recorded;

  • Generally, public hearing but private if parties agree (PD27(4.1)) or r39.2(3) applies. Public means 'court' - includes judge's chambers.

  • Any remedy available on FT or MTC.

Thus, No substantial pre-hearing preparation.

  • Low legal costs.

  • No representation needed.

  • 'Disposal Hearing' can be treated as FH.

As only 1 day, expert evidence will usually be in writing unless necessary for them to attend hearing (r35.5).

Standard Disclosure (r31.6)

Have a Pre-Trial Checklist (PTC) sent not more than 8 weeks before trial date/start of trial window (r278.5(2)), and must have "not less than 2 weeks" to complete (PD28(6.1)(2). Must return by specified date.

If no party completes PTC by specified date, court will order claim struck out if not filed within 7 days.

r26.11 - Claims for libel/slander are tried by judge alone, unless at first CMC party applies for jury trial.

All other cases get jury if application made within 28 days of DS, an Application is made to be tried with jury.

Will give case management directions when allocated to MTC (r29.2). Court may fix CMC/Pre-Trial Review at any time after allocation (r29.3) to determine: amendments, disclosure, expert evidence, further information, split trials, timetables.

Parties should endeavour to agree directions, and submit at least 7 days before CMC - r29.4.

Pretrial Checklist (PTC)

  • r29.6 - Court will send parties PTC ("Listings Questionnaire") for completion, and return by date specified, unless it considers claim can go to trial without PTC.

  • r29.6(3) - If no party files PTC by date specified, court will order that unless filed within 7 days from service of that order, the claim will be struck out without further order. ("Unless Order"!!!)

  • Return date will be at least 8 weeks before...

Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our BPTC Civil Ligitation Notes.

More BPTC Civil Ligitation Samples